
When asked to compare two similar sites in both UX and UI design contexts, I chose to examine Target and Amazon’s mobile apps. These are two apps I frequent often, and through my own usage, I have noticed both pros and cons of the apps. Through a series of Feel and Need statements, I will examine the apps for what works well and what may need to be changed in areas of UX and UI design. First, we must discuss why UX/UI matters when it comes to the consumers using the products or goods we design. The UX design process centres on conducting user research in order to understand who your users are, what problems they face and what they require in terms of a viable solution. This allows us to tailor the experience our consumers have with our product, which can lead to success and further expansion for the product.
When looking at Target’s mobile app through the lenses of UX design, these were my findings. Target’s navigation of its app makes me feel frustrated and troubled, as my needs for efficiency and competence are not being met, as the app has the search bar at the bottom of the homepage of the app, as opposed to the top of the page like most sites. This doesn’t allow me to navigate the site as easily as I would like . Target’s design of its app makes me feel confused and annoyed as my needs for and competence are not being met as the app has a confusing overall design at first glance, I would recommend that they move the search bar to the top and make the categories In a side bar rather than a scroll across bar as It can look limiting to the average consumer. Then I began to look at Target’s app through a UI lens. Target’s colors of its app make me feel content, as my need for trust is being met, as the app has the same familiar branding I’ve come to understand to connect to the brand over my time as a customer. This allows me to trust that my online experience will align similarly to my in-person experience. Target’s buttons on its app make me feel relieved and capable, as my needs for efficiency and competence are being met. The buttons are clearly listed correctly for their function, along with a clear Icon to further direct me towards the action or feature I am looking for.
Then I began to compare Amazon through the aspects that would impact the UX/UI experience for the consumer. Amazon’s navigation on its app makes me feel calm and happy as my needs for efficiency and competence are being met. The navigation of this app, as compared to Target’s, is much easier. In my opinion, while they still have similar design features, the navigation itself feels easier. Amazon’s readability on its app makes me feel content and capable, as my needs for clarity and ease are being met. The app is very readable and has clear categories and headings, which adds to the overall app’s navigation. Amazon’s design on its app makes me feel calm and stimulated as my needs for clarity and information are being met. The app’s design is overall very Intuitive, and I feel it can be attributed to the search bar being at the top of the page and the clear titles for the tiles with their corresponding Images. The bottom bar also has Icons to provide context to each feature. Amazon’s colors on its app make me feel excited and confused, as my needs for recognition and clarity are not being fully met. While this app differs from the target and doesn’t use its brand’s color palette inside its app, the ever-changing aspect is something that can be exciting. My confusion is more so a question of wondering if they do this to make each experience more personal, since there is no In-person experience for shopping through Amazon.
Overall, analyzing the UX/UI experience for apps can allow businesses to tailor their products to their consumer and be able to have successful products and build trust and positive experiences, and connections with their target audience.
Sources:
Stevens, Emily. “The Value of UX Design.” UX Design Institute, 13 Nov. 2023, www.uxdesigninstitute.com/blog/the-value-of-ux-design/
Check out more of my findings in the PDF below:

